Reports of homophobic and transphobic hate crimes in South Yorkshire have risen dramatically over the last four years, according to a Freedom of Information (FOI) request by Now Then.
364 offences were reported to South Yorkshire Police in 2018 that included sexual orientation as a factor. This rose to 443 in 2019, 556 in 2020 and 715 in 2021, an almost 100% increase. In terms of crimes where transphobia was a factor, 75 were reported in 2018, rising to 94 in 2019, dropping to 71 in 2020 but growing again to 106 in 2021. This is a 41% increase.
Some of this rise will be accounted for by more people reporting the crimes they experience, rather than necessarily such a large increase in crime itself. When people feel safer to report hate crimes, this suggests an improving perception of the police as an authority that will take such discrimination seriously. Support from Stop Hate UK no doubt contributes to helping people report, too.
Chief Inspector Mark Goddard, Force Lead for Hate Crime at South Yorkshire Police, told Now Then:
Yet many members of the LGBTQI+ community do not trust the police, with queer venue Dempseys resorting to an open letter to South Yorkshire Police in February:
In response, the police did meet with the venue, who were relieved and pleased at the response:
Despite this positive reaction from the police to the queer club’s concerns, the overall numbers of anti-LGBT hate crimes are far too high and show that South Yorkshire is not as safe a place for LGBTQI+ people as it could be – and should be.
What’s more, few of these crimes have a perpetrator being charged. Last year, the Sheffield Star found that: “Less than three per cent of hate crimes have resulted in a charge when it comes to offences relating to sexual orientation (2.8%), disability (2.98%) and religion (2.7%).”
Even more disturbingly, despite 11 transphobic incidents being reported in the first half of 2021, “No transgender-related hate crimes have resulted in a charge.”
Mark Goddard from South Yorkshire Police went on:
For Sheffield’s queer community to be safe in the city, whether they’re partying, shopping or just living their lives, this dramatic rise in hate crimes – and failure to apprehend and charge perpetrators – must be reversed. Resources must be committed to changing attitudes as well as simply avoiding the worst crimes, and this must go far beyond law enforcement into community initiatives and schools.
In anticipation of next week’s Festival of Debate panel, Rei Takver speaks with Sheffield doctor and HIV specialist Dr Claire Dewsnap about what the city still needs to do to tackle the virus.
Sheffield GP Jack Czauderna explores a fascinating experiment from 100 years ago that turned how we think about health upside down – and that could sit alongside the NHS today.
People in Sheffield are looking at how transitions can be funded in the city, including how our entire economy should be restructured. Do you want to be part of it?